Bravo! Again!

word dementiaIn one of my very first blogs I paid tribute to husband-and-wife actors Timothy West and Prunella Scales for having the courage to speak publicly about Prunella’s dementia, and for doing so in such a constructive manner.  Though acknowledging the difficulties, Mr West said the pair of them still had “a lot of fun”.  Since then the couple have appeared on television and radio, talking about their canal trips and helping to combat the stigma and confusion that clings to the condition.

Now, following a television appearance on Piers’ Morgan’s Life Stories, some in the media have suggested that 81-year-old Mr West compromised his wife’s dignity by talking about her “gradual disappearance” as she sat in the audience and then suggesting that it was okay to do so because “she won’t remember”.

I doubt they need it (they seem a brilliant, resilient bunch these Wests) but I’d like to support what they’ve done.  Not everyone in their position would have made the same decision.  When I wrote my first article about my mum’s dementia in the Sunday Express back in 2006, I did so under a pseudonym, mainly out of respect for my dad, who was so frail that I didn’t want to seek his permission or worry him at all.  No one knew who I was so it didn’t matter.

But a well-known acting dynasty such as the Wests have power and influence the likes of which a nobody such as me can only dream about (or fear).  What they are doing to raise awareness of this misunderstood condition is tremendous – and courageous.   Those of you who are old enough may recall how, in 1965, Richard Dimbleby (“the voice of the nation”) went a long way towards banishing the stigma which then surrounded what we used to call, in hushed tones, the Big C, by announcing on national television that he had testicular cancer.

To me, the Wests’ selfless sharing of their experiences is in much the same mould and, together with the valuable insights of other celebrities such as the late Sir Terry Pratchett (who had Alzheimer’s), helps to increase society’s understanding of the condition through the soft power of culture.

Shortly after the Wests first spoke out about 83-year-old Prunella’s dementia, Sarah Vine of the Daily Mail recounted a touching vignette of the pair she’d witnessed at a literary festival.  She said that they read together on stage quite perfectly.

“But the most touching performance took place during rehearsals.  West never took his eyes off his wife, making sure she knew the running order, patiently going over everything time and again, tenderly coaching her when she got in a muddle.  It was a humbling display of unshakeable marital love”. I don’t always agree with the Daily Mail’s view of the world, but I thought this was a lovely, astute piece of observation.

In another, very different, publication, journalist Rebecca Ley reviewed a radio programme on dementia in which Joan Bakewell interviewed her old friend Prunella Scales.  Writing in the Guardian, Rebecca described the actress’s voice as “a revelation”.

Though slightly slowed, it was still grand and full of warmth and wit, Rebecca said, and “immediately shredded any notion that her diagnosis has erased the person she used to be”, adding that the interaction between husband and wife revealed a marriage that was still very much alive.  “We need more of this kind of broadcasting, to shine a light into the abyss,” she wrote.  How right she was.

Rebecca honestly and very movingly recounted her own father’s final years with dementia in the Guardian and I’d urge anyone who hasn’t discovered her past columns to read them online.  She knows the pain and heartache of being a carer, and the soul-searching and strength needed to write about it publicly.

A few months ago I wrote a blog about a Radio 4 interview in which the Today programme’s resident Rottweiler John Humphrys talked to the wife of someone with dementia.  It was an extraordinary few minutes that revealed quite a different side to the normally cantankerous Welshman.  More importantly, because of the calm, insightful words of his interviewee Denise, it shone a penetrating spotlight on what it is to be the family carer of someone with the condition.  Taking my cue from something that Denise said, I called my blog “The Unending Grief of the Dementia Carer”.  I think it just about sums up what this thoughtful, articulate woman had to say – you can still hear the interview here.

Along with the never-ending grief, as anyone with a relative with dementia knows, comes pain, often confusion and almost always guilt.

So for commentators to heap more guilt on the Wests, strikes me as pretty low.  We are all different and we all have our own way of dealing with life’s ups and downs, dementia included.  I don’t know who it was who first said that when you’ve met one person with dementia, you’ve met one person with dementia.  But he or she was right. And the same goes for the relatives of those with dementia: our reactions are unique.

I applaud the Wests.  Their love for one another has been obvious for all to see and the decision to speak out will not have been taken lightly.   The actors’ carefully chosen words have more power and influence than most and certainly more than mine – and I offer them both, for the second time, a very loud, “Bravo!”

13 Responses to Bravo! Again!

  1. Jan Inman 17th December 2015 at 5:55 pm #

    Bravo indeed it was a very touching and lovely interview , and I applaud his decision their love for each other shined through .
    And I hope they have a wonderful Christmas together .
    Once again Pippa Bravo.

    Much love to you and your family and Bert have a Happy and healthy Christmas and New Year.
    Love Jan.xxxxxx

    • Pippa Kelly 17th December 2015 at 6:09 pm #

      Much love to you too Jean. I know this will be a very difficult time for you without your wonderful Ron. I hope that 2016 brings you some happiness and very much better health. You certainly deserve it.

      • Jan Inman 17th December 2015 at 8:54 pm #

        Thank you Pippa.xxxx

  2. Vicki Tapia 17th December 2015 at 6:01 pm #

    Well done, Pippa! Having had both parents dealt the dementia hand, I couldn’t agree more.

    • Pippa Kelly 17th December 2015 at 6:09 pm #

      Thanks Vicki!

  3. Heather Pearson 17th December 2015 at 6:13 pm #

    Bravo Pippa, thanks for making these points- well said.

    Having a Mother in year 19 of Early Onset Alzheimer’s Disease, I couldn’t agree more.

  4. Jean 17th December 2015 at 9:26 pm #

    Beautifully written, Pippa. It is so wrong for anyone to judge. Raising awareness through speaking of such loving actions and tender care within the partnership is what should be remembered. Thank you for writing this thoughtful article,

    • Pippa Kelly 18th December 2015 at 10:29 am #

      Thanks Jean. I hope that you and your family have a lovely Christmas and a happy and healthy new year!

  5. Dr. Deborah Forrest 18th December 2015 at 1:18 pm #

    Bravo to the Wests and to you Pippa for sharing this story with the public. Like you, I support the Wests efforts to put a loving face on dementia. Sharing their love for each other in such a public fashion can only help others to see a warm and caring view of a disease that takes so much. Anyone who can help to erase any form of shaming or laying on any form of guilt is to be applauded.

    My best wishes go out to the Wests and to you Pippa for Joyous Holiday Season.

  6. Pippa Kelly 21st December 2015 at 12:39 pm #

    Many thanks Deborah. It’s lovely when people take time to comment on my blogs. All the very best to you for the festive season.

  7. Lou 24th December 2015 at 10:37 am #

    Pippa – I’m with my Daddy – we are both missing my mummy dreadfully who was taking from us just like yours was. We mourned her loss long before she died.

    By the way – not only did I love your article in the Telegraph today, but I adore your shirt – please tell me where you got it – I have to have one!

  8. David Wright 24th December 2015 at 7:34 pm #

    Well, Pippa Kelly! You got me there! Delia and I have just watched the Kings College Service together for the umpteenth time, her smiling and joining in and me intermittently weeping for it is certainly the last time we will share the moment. Then I read your piece in the Telegraph. More gulping and swallowing!
    Have you heard of BUDI? Bounemouth University Dementia Unit, when funds permit conveen the BUDI orchestra. A mix of professional musicians, helpers and dementia sufferers and carers get together to make music. We are given violins(!) and play everything from jigs to “You are my sunshine. After three rehearsal sessions we give a public concert. Delia can’t join in too much these days but she is totally immersed in the music and for a couple of hours it is as though we have her back! It is astonishing how the music works some sort of magic.

    I hope that the stuffing goes down well – even a recipe gives a sort of immortality!

    Best wishes from Delia and David

    • Pippa Kelly 26th December 2015 at 10:28 pm #

      Many thanks David – and Delia. I think I may well have to come down to Bournemouth to check out your orchestra, which I think I read about in an Arts4Dementia paper .. ? Perhaps we can stay in touch – you can contact me through my website.

Leave a Reply